Digital Fantasy No More?

akief Blog Posts, HBHE 680 4 Comments

Is there a link between violent video game playing and violence in real-life? This question has been around for quite some time, but as a result of recent gun related violence, it is taking center stage again.  This past week, an article was published in the New York Times titled “Shooting in the Dark.” This article highlights the complexities that arise when suggesting there may be a link between violent video game playing and the manifestation of violent behavior in real life. The author begins the piece by saying that the young men who committed such atrocities as Columbine and the movie theater shooting in Colorado, share the characteristic of acting out a “digital fantasy.” But, is this actually the case?

Photo by FireFish45 via Flickr.com

 

The author of the NYTimes piece states that researchers have clarified that “playing the games can and does stir hostile urges and mildly aggressive behavior in the short term.” This is a beneficial finding, but speculation still remains on the subjective nature of ‘mildly aggressive behavior’ and what happens after the ‘short term’.  In fact, Psychologist Michael R. Ward states, “I don’t know that a psychological study can ever answer that question definitively.”

It is intuitive that young kids who play violent video games, compared to young kids who do not play violent video games, will be more aggressive in certain real-life situations. Thus, it is not surprising that the violent video game playing kids may get into more scuffles here and there during recess, as indicated by research results.

So do scuffles at recess potentially fueled by violent video game playing lead to planning and executing mass homicides later in life? This is where the research gap exists, and might always exist, but it doesn’t mean we should stop looking for the answer.

 

http://www.nytimes.com/2013/02/12/science/studying-the-effects-of-playing-violent-video-games.html?_r=0

Comments 4

  1. It would be interesting to see what is found after some of the research gaps here are closed. You would think that a virtual video game wouldn’t have much of an effect on people but some researchers believe it does. I do think that age is something that should be considered. The younger the individual is at onset of playing video games, the more likely they may be to apply the game violence to real life. Adolescents are greater influence b their surroundings.

  2. I have always found this topic quite interesting as it pertains to gun violence. There are literally millions of violent video games sold each year, so what does this say about the millions of youth that do not commit such violent acts? In fact, I would think that most youth that play violent video games still lead healthy lives and exhibit prosocial behavior. The heavy weight that is put on violent video games when it comes to the perpetrators of mass shootings is not fair. There are much deeper issues to consider when millions of other youth never act out in this way. Of all the different factors that may cause a youth to commit a violent crime like a mass shooting, I think the focus on violent gaming is off base. I do not want to discredit the research that shows more aggressive behavior in the short term for youth that play violent video games, I just do not think this part of the conversation should be the focal point.

  3. Thanks for your write-up. What I want to point
    out is that while searching for a good internet
    electronics store, look for a web-site with complete information on critical indicators such as the level of privacy statement, protection details, payment options, and various terms as well as policies.
    Usually take time to see the help along with FAQ segments to get
    a far better idea of how a shop is effective, what they are capable of doing for you, and in what way you
    can make the most of the features.