Reducing Recidivism for Juvenile Criminal Offenders

Brittany Bostic Blog Posts 7 Comments

Juvenile criminal behavior is something that Americans are all too familiar with. Through local and national news coverage we often hear about burglaries, thefts, and murders committed by adolescents. One thing that mainstream media fails to report is how the criminal justice system works with youth to decrease recidivism and increase rehabilitation.

According to the U.S. Department of Justice recidivism is the repetition of criminal behavior.  There is no national recidivism rate for juveniles since juvenile justice systems vary across states, however recidivism is a huge problem among this population. With Florida, New York, and Virginia leading in rearrests according to the U.S. Department of Justice Juvenile Offenders and Victims 2006 National Report (see figure below).

Juvinele recidivism rates

High recidivism rates that were reported led me to question, what rehabilitation statutes and/or programs are put into place to help eradicate or at least decrease repetition of criminal behavior among juveniles?

As I researched  this topic I found a thorough meta-analyses that synthesized a review of effective and ineffective interventions aimed at decreasing recidivism in juveniles (Lipsey, 2009).

Lipsey identified seven intervention philosophies;

  1. Surveillance (close monitoring)
  2.  Deterrence (deter re-offenses by dramatizing negative consequences)
  3. Discipline (structured regimens)
  4. Restorative programs (repair harm done by offenders; restitution, mediation (apology by offender))
  5. Counseling and its variants (individual, family, group, peer, mentoring, mixed)
  6. Skill building programs (behavioral, cognitive, social, academic, and job skill training)
  7. Multiple coordinated services (case management, service broker, and multimodal regimen)

Lispsey’s meta-analyses revealed that:

Counseling interventions had the largest positive effects on recidivism decreasing it by 13%, followed by Multiple coordinated services (12%), and Skill building programs (12%). The counseling interventions that were most effective were group-based, mentoring focused, and those that had mixed combinations of various types of counseling.

Whereas, discipline interventions had the largest negative effects on recidivism with an increase of 8%, with deterrence interventions increasing recidivism by 2%.

This information was easy to find and is readily available for public and state use, but is it used? How many boot camp programs have you heard of? And “Scared Straight” programs (youth visiting prisons, deterrence) have become a norm, but what about its effectiveness.Would it make a difference if these interventions were run the same state by state, what do you think? What questions do you think we need to ask our juvenile justice system about their effectiveness to reduce recidivism among juvenile offenders?


Lipsey, M. 2009. The primary factors that characterized effective interventions with juvenile offenders: A meta-analytic overview. Victims & Offenders: An International Journal of Evidence-based Research, Policy, and Practice. 4(2) 124-147.

Snyder, H., and Sickmund, M. 2006. Juvenile offenders and victims: 2006 national report. U.S. Department of Justice. Office of Justice Programs. Office of Juvenile Justice and Delinquency Programs.


Comments 7

  1. For different materials should have a different approach.
    The Jordan eleven stands head and shoulders above all of the other footwear that make up the
    most sought soon after line of basketball sneakers in the historical past of sneakers.
    Most people can’t afford this option, of course, but you should never wear your
    basketball shoes after they’ve become worn out because you will regret
    it later with foot and ankle problems, or any other injury you
    can think of.

  2. Admiring the persistence you put into your site and in depth information you provide.
    It’s awesome to come across a blog every once in a while that isn’t the same out of date rehashed material.
    Great read! I’ve saved your site and I’m adding your RSS feeds
    to my Google account.

  3. After exploring a few of the articles on your web page, I honestly like your way of blogging.
    I saved it to my bookmark webpage list and will be checking back soon. Please visit
    my web site too and let me know what you

  4. You will not lose all by throwing away the wreckage.
    But with such a company, you don’t have to worry beecause they always have something to
    offer no matter what kind of car they have to take away.
    If it is a collectors’ item then you will certainly bbe able to find
    interested buyers. Irrespective of the car you drive,
    care and maintenance is critical. This is a service that you
    will find with most of the online companies.

  5. Thhe basic rule observed is that losses suffered by passive activities cannot bee used or applied as a reduction to the income generated
    by non-passive activities. Before you seelect one, compre
    them so that you get a good deal. We have every type of orkut,
    facebook, twityter and other major socual networking scraps, and all are FREE ORKUT
    SCRAPS,we have frree latest Orkut Scraps, Popular Orkut Scraps,
    Frkendship Orkut Scraps, Day Comments, Greetingg Wishes, Festival
    Scraps. In fact, you can even place your advertisement in the local newspapers and other magazines.
    These are just a few ways that you can sell your used orr junk car.